Smells Like Humans
Top 5% global podcast! Smells Like Humans is a seasonal podcast dedicated to bringing a humorous perspective to quirky and curious aspects of human behavior. Each show, the SLH crew will focus on a different topic, and share personal stories and observations in a way that sounds like you’re hanging out with your funny friends. The stories and commentary are presented with humor and warmth, since let’s face it: we all smell like humans. (Contact us: contactSLH19581980@gmail.com)
Smells Like Humans
THE DEATH OF THE SECRET FAMILY
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Jaimee joins Ross to discuss secret families and how it is harder to get away with them. They also discuss Jaimee's unusual fishing ritual.
Contact us: contactSLH19581980@gmail.com
Where's my money pops? My pants are filled with fish.
SPEAKER_02Fish to bash. Alright.
SPEAKER_04I've got fish to bash. Welcome to another episode of Smells Like Humans. This is the podcast where we explore the curious things that people do, the very human things that grab our attention and cause us to wonder what and why. I'm Ross, your host, and my guest today is a real cracker jack of a human who is so groovy she makes a vintage John Coltrane LP jealous. It's Jamie.
SPEAKER_03I don't know who that is.
SPEAKER_04Well, that's okay. Jamie, it's great to have you. We're in the middle of season five here. Five seasons of what we call our little show, and we are glad that you out there are tuning in and listening, and we appreciate your support. We consider you part of our family. You are welcome here. Come as you are, be as you are, and have a good time. Jamie, we know that humans like to keep their secrets. Secrets. We all got them. We all got secrets. There's nobody you know that doesn't have a secret. We just don't know what it is because it's a secret. So today I want to focus on a secret that some people keep more than you think, that I find really fascinating. And that secret is a secret family, huh? And I'm specifically focusing on cats who create a whole other family, like kids, home, holidays, birthdays, sending a kid to college. They maintain the two families for their entire life until they croak, and nobody knows about them.
SPEAKER_03Crazy.
SPEAKER_04Until maybe at the funeral when they're who are these other people? Right. What are you people doing here? What are you doing here? And then it's the big reveal. So have you ever heard of these secret families or shadow families that they're sometimes called?
SPEAKER_03I mean, I watch a lot of true crime and I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts. You're the expert. Oftentimes there is like my dad had a whole ass other family, and I had no idea. And I do not understand how you keep that up.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's really fascinating. It's such a complicated thing to pull off, I think. I mean, it what that's such a lot of work you've got to do to keep the plate spinning. So some famous uh secret families. Arnold Schwarzenegger had a secret secret relationship that he kept for Maria Schreiber and a secret kid. Wow. There was this Senator John Edwards who denied he had a secret family, but he did. Loretta Young. I Charles Lindbergh, the aviator, remember this cat with the airplane, and he was so famous. Okay. Charles Lindbergh was the Taylor Swift of his era. Have you written this down? Because I feel like people are going to be flocking to this take. But he was very, very famous at the time, but this is back in the day when they didn't have anything. He had not one, not two, he had three secret families.
SPEAKER_03That's crazy. Like, especially the people that like live with their family. Yes. Like you live with them enough that they are familiar with you. You like have a toothbrush there and stuff. It's not like you're there for a week out of the year. It's like you're there all the time. How do you have three different families and you are there all the time?
SPEAKER_04Well, it usually turns out that the people it back in the day who got away with this, traveling was an important part of their job. Yeah, if you're a pilot, pilot truck drivers, yeah. Anybody who salespeople, anybody who was always traveling around would be gone for periods of time. It was normal. Yeah. And so they could spend a week a month, or maybe even two with a secret family. But well, you got three secret families. I don't even know how you do that. I don't even know how you keep the names straight. You know, Gertrude, Gretel, what the hell is your name? In the Lindbergh case, the second families remained entirely unknown to the public and his American relatives until DNA tests and investigations revealed the truth decades after his death. So he thought he got away with it. In 1974, they did the test. They said, This dude has like 50 families. There was one that I think it's because this person was a TV per personality that I somehow would watch. So his was a lot more relevant to me. This guy's name was Charles Gerald.
SPEAKER_00I'm Charles Gerald, and this is Sunday morning, a 90-minute CBS news program that starts right now. Every Sunday morning we're going to bring you the news, of course, but we're going to spend most of this hour and a half together trying to explain what's happening to ourselves and to you. And we're not going to hurry through it. We have time for a background story on a major event, so we'll have a background story every week. We have time to talk about art and music and books and movies, so we'll do that. Sports of course.
SPEAKER_04But he was a very folksy everyday guy. Like had the receding hairline, he's a little dumpy, and he just had this folksy manner. Like, good morning. Well, today we're gonna get in our Winnebago and we're gonna go to a Tumwa, Iowa. Uh-huh. And we are gonna go to the Pickle Festival. It was stuff like that. Yeah, but it was stuff. You said I'm there. Okay, I'm suddenly paying attention. Now you've got my interest. So this was like more modern times, although it's still before, of course, our current time. But it was considered, you know, pretty amazing to discover after he died that for 29 years, this folksy host of CBS's On the Road and CBS's Sunday morning, he lived a meticulously managed double life. He had a separate shadow family that lived along a trout stream in Montana. It was a trout stream family. So he met this woman in 60, 1968, Patricia Elizabeth Shannon. She had three kids and they began a relationship that lasted for 30 years. He died in 97, says here. So 30 years he's in this relationship with her and his kids. So he supported his wife, his secret wife, and he raised the three children as his own, paid for their housing, funded their college uh tuitions, even bought her son his first baseball mitt, which is a real cool dad thing. Here's your first baseball mitt, son, and let me show you how to break it in.
SPEAKER_03I'm curious, like that secret wife has to know that he has another family, right? She must know. He's on television. Like I understand the main wife not knowing because she's like the front, right? But like the secret wife, she must know.
SPEAKER_04Well, the th these a lot of these secret families, they claim they didn't know because of this guy. So this guy, every week, he was on the road. The name of his show is on the road. So he was traveling all the time because he had to, of course, tape the shows and then they had to produce them. So he was always gone. So, you know, if he is able to maintain whatever he does with his real family, but he's always gone, then I could see where they'd be like, Well, he's always gone, but when he's here, he's like it's always been like this.
SPEAKER_03So I guess you don't have like Google and Wikipedia or whatever at that time.
SPEAKER_04That is the key. That is the key, and that is the reason why I think now we're not gonna have any more secrets.
SPEAKER_03That's why we don't have serial killers.
SPEAKER_04I know we've talked about that. We've talked about that before. No more serial killers, not like the kind we've had where it goes on for years and they write letters into the paper to taunt the police. Like, you can't get away with anything. And that's why the secret families aren't gonna happen anymore. Because you're there's such a digital footprint, there's too many ways for people to find out. Like, like his wife today would just throw one of those little Apple tracker things in a suitcase and then an air tag, yeah. And then it's like, dude, what are you doing on a trout stream in Montana for three weeks? I thought you were in Cleveland.
SPEAKER_03But also, there's so many like fame chasers now and people that want to get like recognition online for being with a famous person or something like that, that like I think now people don't care as much about the significant other. Because like they obviously know that you have a wife or a husband or whatever, but if you're famous or like this guy that you were talking about, like on the news, right? He's not like famous, famous, but he's like fame adjacent, right? Like I don't think that people care as much about the significant other, like they just want to be fame adjacent.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's interesting. I hadn't thought about that. Yeah, that would be sort of a magnet for that kind of person. According to what I read, the the secret didn't come out until after he died, and Shannon I had received a letter from him from his deathbed. Oh it's a deathbed letter he sent to her that said he was gonna make sure she inherited their ninety ninety nine oh acre fishing retreat in Montana. So I made it sounds I made it sound like it was just a little cabin on the stream, 90 acres. That's that's real. We're swimming in droughts. But his will said his wife in New York gets everything. And he all, by the way, he had two daughters in his first family as well. So Shannon got this letter, he dies, and she's like, Hey, I get this. He told me I get this. Yeah, and so then the wife finds out about the secret family, and she's like, What? Like, first of all, 30 years and what? Yeah, and you're taking some of this estate because I don't know what that was worth. It was probably a pretty big chunk of change in the 90s. So, what does the nineties have to do with it? I don't know. Okay, so so eventually the Supreme Court of Montana ruled in her favor and recognized his final handwritten note as a valid codicil to his will. So she got her 90-acre trout farm. Or trout farm or fishing village.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Now I don't fish.
SPEAKER_03No.
SPEAKER_04Now I've been fishing. I've been fishing on, I've done light cut.
SPEAKER_03I have actually gone fishing for trout, rainbow trout.
SPEAKER_04And did you catch it? Yes. Do you like fishing?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and my dad like bashed its head with a rock. It was very traumatic.
SPEAKER_04Okay, that's weird. Like, why?
SPEAKER_03You gotta kill it. It was still flipping around after you caught it.
SPEAKER_04Wow. My childhood. Yikes.
SPEAKER_03Anyways.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you got stuff. You got issues, but that's why you're on this show. You're on this show for just that reason. I don't really like fishing, although I've done all the kinds of fishing. I've done deep sea fishing, fishing off a dock, fishing out of a boat. Yeah. I've done what's it called? Fly fishing. I went fly fishing. Some guy tried to teach me how to fly fish. I caught zero.
SPEAKER_03You didn't get a bash anymore. But I no, I didn't get to bash anything. I mean, I would have liked that part.
SPEAKER_04I just don't I understand, like I truly get it, that some people really love it. Like it's just like if they could just do anything, they'd just be fishing all the time. Not me. It doesn't work for me. Right. It doesn't, I don't get anything out of it. Yeah. It's like when I was 18 and I could go to my first strip club. It's like, this is man, this is gonna be so great. And then I'm gonna so horrifying. I just could never get anything out of it. Yeah. I did go a few more times, but I never got anything out of it.
SPEAKER_03You gotta make sure.
SPEAKER_04Uh well, it just seemed like it would be, it seems like it should be good. I get it. It seems like fishing should be good. Right. Fishing is like going to a strip club for me. Yeah. That's that's what it's like. Except there's no head bashing. Hopefully, in either place. In either place. Get out of line. There is always a guy. Right. Usually a guy who will bash your head. Twenty-two percent. First of all, it's hard to know what the real number is because if it's a family, if it's a secret, you never find out about it. And most people aren't famous, so you never hear about it, right? Even if it becomes known later. 22% of all discovered family secrets, so we're talking about a small piece of the pie, involves a secret family or a completely hidden second life. Isn't that interesting? That's one out of five. That's crazy. So, but that's one out of five family secrets. So, you know, that's that's a subsample of the larger sum, not one out of five families, but one out of five families when we're talking about to have some kind of secret, it's a double life or a secret family. And I just think it's fascinating. It's really interesting. It's really, really interesting. And another statistic that stood out to me is 30% of the men tested in paternity cases turn out not to be the biological father.
SPEAKER_03Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_04Isn't that interesting?
SPEAKER_03Also, is it usually a man? I would assume.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think it's usually a man. I think it's almost always a man, but it's probably not exclusive. There's always exceptions. But they tend to have the travel thing in common. Like they're they're, you know, any occupation, usually man's occupation, you know, at the time is primarily men who were like truck drivers or military or international businessmen, right? Regional salesmen. They're always on the road.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So that was how this Charles Caralt dude justified. It was a great cover story. I gotta go.
SPEAKER_03I'm on I feel like a lot of serial killers also are like truck drivers or whatever, you know. Oh, yeah. You have like a like the happy face killer had like a whole family and wife and kids and everything. I didn't know they caught the happy face guy. Oh yeah. I didn't know they ever caught the happy face guy. When did they catch Happy Jay? Oh my god, it's years real. Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah. His daughter has a new show. His daughter has daughter has a show where she interviews other kids that have or not maybe not kids, but other people that are like related to a serial killer.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and then she's not the only kid.
SPEAKER_03No, like BTK, you know, his daughter who looks just like him. She's like if you put a wig on that guy, that's yikes.
SPEAKER_04So this is I get the this is the modern trajectory for all children is that you know, if you have a serial killer father, you at least will have some sort of a career.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you got a podcast.
SPEAKER_04Guaranteed, you got a podcast, you might get a show or special. Yikes. The the other thing that happens, apparently it's very common according to estate lawyers where people make this deathbed confession that you know I have this. Oh by the way, right? This might come up. There might be a few people at the funeral that my real family doesn't recognize. So just saying, how much how long do I have, by the way? About another day, good. So I think that's because if once this gets out, someone's gonna come here and pull my tubes. So yeah, so so that people will confess to these secret lives on their deathbed and try to, and that's what he did. He tried to clean up this little problem with his will, but he didn't change his actual will, which would also have been something he could have done. But he didn't do that, so even in the end, he was kind of screwing it up. But yeah, so but now it's thought it would be really hard with their digital footprints, interconnected banking, social media algorithms, all the tracking stuff, you know, just stuff where people are like, people you may know, you know, you still like tagging you in a photo, all that stuff makes it it it the idea of maintaining what's called a parallel family or a shadow family seems less and less likely. And then, of course, you know, what a horrible thing to discover as a kid in either family. You know, the kids in Charles's shadow family called them pops.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_04Well, and then you find out pops is pops to all kinds of people, right? So this is traumatic for a lot of even as they're either grown people. They I mean, how would you feel if this happened to you? Yeah, because you have you've had trauma in your life, but you haven't had secret families or have you.
SPEAKER_03I know, right? Yeah, it would be horrifying. It would be kind of like you know, finding out that your parent was a serial killer. It would be, you know, it's like a whole secret life, and like you think you know this person and you don't actually know them. Right.
SPEAKER_04And that is one of the key things that happens to kids as even as they are become adults, is they learn that all of this was a lie. This whole relationship was a lie. I mean, they might have had a real relationship with this person, but what they thought they knew was a lie.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_04And if that's a lie, what else is fake? So they actually become, you know, this they just get into this kind of circle of distrust, like who can I believe, you know, and what can I believe? They're angry, they grieve because they had this image of the person and they're not who they seem to be. I'm just wondering, as you sit here today, could you lead a secret life?
SPEAKER_03Oh no, absolutely. Could you have a secret? I don't even like to leave my house generally. I came here for this, but I I like to stay home.
SPEAKER_04You don't like to get out of my house. Be really hard. You'd have to have a big house.
SPEAKER_03I would be yeah. I would have to leave my house more often. It's like I I only leave my house for my job, and my job's like very social. So I go and I talk to people, and then I come home and I don't want to do anything or go anywhere. I just want to watch a scary movie and have my dinner on my couch. Like, no, I could absolutely not lead a double life.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Who has the time or the energy?
SPEAKER_04The energy.
SPEAKER_03I could never.
SPEAKER_04The energy. I mean, I think when I was trying to imagine what this would be like to have a secret other family. And the first thing that popped into my head, it should have been the guilt, but which it would be for me. I would feel guilty every day.
SPEAKER_03I'm not a good liar. Yeah. I I would just feel horrible.
SPEAKER_04It's like it's like, you know, it's not that I haven't made mistakes, but it's like I know the difference between right and wrong. I couldn't morally justify it. It would be eating at me every day.
SPEAKER_03100%.
SPEAKER_04So, but before that, the first thing I wrote to say, what would what would really be hard about this for me? It's the feeling feeling like I could never relax. No, you can never relax because you always have to be maintaining not only the secret scene, yeah. It's it's a job, it's like another job, but then you've got all these people you have to maintain.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, okay. Number one, I don't want to have kids ever at all. So that's number one. So number one, that. And then number two, just like I I so me and my husband will like have dinner, watch a movie, and then I'm like, go away. Go play video games or whatever. I want to watch my m murder documentaries. Right. To think about having to try and have the energy for more than that. I'm good for one movie. I like you for one movie.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you're one movie boy.
SPEAKER_03And then and then go do your own thing. And I want to do my own thing. Right. When would you ever have time for yourself to do your own stuff that you like?
SPEAKER_04There's no time. No. And and even if there's time, it's just I was thinking of the mental space that I don't have. Yes. Because these people are in my head. All of the people, so all the kids and all the stuff they're going through, and their stuff and their issues, and the other spouse, the other wife, the other partner, like you're managing whatever's going on there.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_04And like you maybe there's times when you're in an argument with both of them. Yeah. You know, and now you're like just trying to.
SPEAKER_03How do you remember? How do you keep things straight?
SPEAKER_04That's the third thing I wrote down.
SPEAKER_03I could not.
SPEAKER_04You cannot have a slip up.
SPEAKER_03No.
SPEAKER_04No sleep talking. And I used to be a big sleep talker.
SPEAKER_03Really?
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah. And a sleepwalker.
SPEAKER_03Oh wow.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I'd wander around saying all kinds of stuff. I mean, I didn't know what I was doing. Right. But I would do it.
SPEAKER_03You were having a great time.
SPEAKER_04I just I wasn't aware that I was doing it.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_04And, you know, and I did that from a kid. And then finally I grew out of it or got too lazy.
SPEAKER_03Right. You were very tired. I just want to go to sleep. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I don't got time. And then it's just like, so see, we can't slip up. You can't like use the wrong name. You can't be saying, you know, and his parallel wife was named Shannon. He can't be saying, Shannon the fish, fish, Shannon, the fish, Shannon, Shannon the fish. And then your wife's like, Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, who are you talking about? Shannon? I don't know. I don't know. Hey, I gotta go. And then all the birthdays. We were talking about birthdays in the last episode.
SPEAKER_03Birthdays are for kids.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So we're talking about birthdays, but all those birthdays remember like man. That's too much. And you gotta be there. Because if your pops, pops has to be there for the birthdays. I think it's too much work. I would just work. I would just feel so psychically unstable all that time. I would just and even if you were all by yourself sitting on a rock in the middle of the desert, you would still be haunted by all these feelings of all these things, even if you didn't mind having the shadow family. But then it's like, well, how would I really feel if I found out as an adult that my father or mother had a secret family? How would I feel?
SPEAKER_03I mean, I wouldn't be surprised about mine, but mine isn't an exception.
SPEAKER_04You're not you're not.
SPEAKER_03I would not be surprised by anything.
SPEAKER_04You can't surprise me.
SPEAKER_03You cannot surprise me.
SPEAKER_04My father did travel a lot for work. He fits into the category of a person who is always traveling. I would have two primary feelings. One would be, and I don't know which one would actually be stronger, but one would feel a little cheated.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Because I say, wait a minute. So you weren't here, you were traveling all this time because you were having a a family. Yeah, right. Like you were giving them the attention you should have been giving us. Yeah. So maybe there'd be some of that. Like that's kind of sucks. Right. But then the next feeling, and again, it might even be stronger, would be curiosity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so the curiosity would be why?
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_04And then how did you pull this off? And who are these other people? Yeah. Like I'd want to know who they were. Like I wouldn't be mad at them. Yeah. I'd kind of want to know who are these suckers? Yeah. Like, and you know, are they half, are they like half brothers and sisters, or was this a family, you know, did he get involved with a pre-existing family, like good old Charles Caralt did? Because that's that's to me, that's really fascinating. It's like, what goes through your head when I get that you meet someone and you fall in love with them? And I get that that you would carry on an affair for some period of time. Yeah. I get it. I get how that happens. But 30 years of separate family, yeah, that I that is I I'm gonna guess that the reason like you keep this going is like, well, I'm kinda okay being married with this first person, and I kind of like that life that we have. I don't really necessarily like her as much as I did or whatever that is, but I kind of like this life, and I certainly can't afford a divorce and don't want to go through all that. I don't want to move, I don't want to upset the kids. So I'm just gonna keep this secret relationship going.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I guess that's kind of what they must think about.
SPEAKER_03So I was just thinking, so my dad is gay, right? And he the reason that I exist is because he was Mormon, right? And they told him that if he got married, that it would like cure him of being gay and it didn't work out or whatever. Right. So like in that kind of aspect, maybe I could understand it where it's like you're married to a lady.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03This was the 80s and 90s, you know. You're married to a lady to keep a front in in that realm. Right. And then you have a secret relationship like with a man. Right. You know, obviously you're not gonna have kids. I mean, uh, you could adopt kids, I suppose, you know, like, but in that aspect, I do kind of understand like having the secret family relationship because you kind of have to at the time.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So that makes sense, doesn't it? You just reminded me like in Hollywood, old Hollywood for sure, and probably still now, that that that there were it was usually men who pretended to be straight and they would have relationships or or yeah, or that you know, arranged by the studios or whatever to create this to maintain their image of this viral hetero dude. And not just because of that, because of their image, but because you know, back then, yeah, being gay was not cool. Yeah, it's not cool to be gay and be in the movies. How can that be?
SPEAKER_03How can it be impossible? How can it be you can be a leading man and be gay?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, how could it be?
SPEAKER_03It can't happen.
SPEAKER_04So I find the secret families really interesting. I don't know why it's so fascinating to me. It's just, I guess the complexity of it is what I started saying at the beginning of the show. It's just as I think about it, I just think, wow, it's worse than having two jobs. Yes. If you're considering a secret family or currently maintaining one, our recommendation is exactly.
SPEAKER_03I couldn't I mean it's exhausting. Just come clean.
SPEAKER_04Come clean.
SPEAKER_03Just come clean.
SPEAKER_04Well, how liberating to come clean, straighten it out. Such a relief. Clarify your life, uh, simplify. You know, it's like you throw away like old clothes and stuff out of your closet, and you feel better because you're gonna feel better. Throw away that extra kid.
SPEAKER_03Because you're gonna pay a lot of money for a divorce.
SPEAKER_04Gonna be expensive all the way around.
SPEAKER_03Very expensive.
SPEAKER_04And then the trout people are coming for you. The fish people, like, where's where's my money, Pops? My pants are filled with fish.
SPEAKER_02Fish to bash. All right.
SPEAKER_04I've got I've got fish to bash. Well, this has been a lot of fun to talk about secret families. Thank you for indulging me, Jamie. And thank you to everyone out there for joining us for this episode. Do us a favor and share the show with somebody you think would like whatever it is we do here. You know what we do. If you're listening, you know exactly what we do, you know why you like it, you probably know somebody who also would like it. And so we appreciate that you're here and we appreciate your support. And we hope you will tune into another episode because whether you are thinking about starting a whole ass other family, or just bashing a fish along a stream in Montana, it's important to remember that we all smell like humans. Goodbye, everybody. Do us a fave. Is that a thing? I don't know. Any slang, I don't know how people talk. It's about to be. Yeah, I don't know.